Archive for the 'review' Category

Friday, March 21st, 2008

Life on Mars

As part of the FourStarters relaunch we decided to broaden what we blog about, so here is a post that really has to be put in a new category to make sense on our blog.

I consume a lot of media. Books, music, news, internet radio, audio and video podcasts, movies, and most importantly: television series. I know that at least Reinier shares this interest in TV series with me (just ask him about Firefly and he won’t shut up) so I decided to give a write-up of one of the series that has kept me busy the last few weeks.

Life on Mars

Life On Mars

Life on Mars is a 16 episode (2 seasons) BBC drama about Sam Tyler (played by John Simm), a Detective Chief Inspector for the Manchester Metropolitan Police, who has an accident and wakes up in 1973. The big question is if he is in a coma and dreaming it, if he is dead, or if he travelled through time.

Back in 1973 he joins the force as a detective inspector and finds that he has trouble fitting in. His boss, Gene Hunt (played by Philip Glenister) is an alcoholic, racist, sexist, homophobe that never learned to do an investigation by the book. This makes stuff very interesting for the viewer with Sam and Gene often either punching each other or co-punching another. Not to mention the weird hair cuts and cloths to add to the effect of the viewer wondering wether Sam really ended up on Mars.

(more…)

Tuesday, September 11th, 2007

Hands-On: The New iPod Lineup

iPod Nano 3GAs I said, Reinier and I were in the Apple Store Regent Street yesterday, mainly to have a look at the Apple Store, but also to have a look at the new iPods. Apple announced a complete update to their iPod lineup last week, most notably replacing the iPod Nano with a new smaller version and introducing a new iPod Touch that is based on the iPhone interface.

Although the iPod Touch was the big announcement, it isn’t available yet in store. Still, the iPod Nano and iPod Classic (the new name for the old style iPod) have gotten a few updates that really make a difference, so we had a look at those. I didn’t bring my camera so I don’t have any photo’s, I hope to get some of the iPod Touch once it’s in store.

The iPod Nano got the biggest update as it is now comes in a way smaller form factor and is able to play video. Bringing video to the entire iPod lineup (except the shuffle) is important to Apple as well as many other players like Podcasters. When I tried the new iPod Nano, I noticed that the video playback is “just fine” as it can only be so much impressive on a 2″ screen. Yes, the resolution is sharp and the playback is smooth, but I rather watch stuff on my Macbook if I can.

iPod Nano 3G InterfaceThe iPod Classic and iPod Nano both got a new interface update, giving them both Cover Flow and a new split screen interface for certain views. We noticed that the iPod Nano is much faster in starting up and powering down than its predecessor, but somehow sometimes felt a bit slow in navigating and especially when scrolling through a whole lot of photos. Reinier noted that scrolling through photos is much smoother on his iPod Nano 2G.

To see if this scrolling went any smoother on the new iPod Classic, I looked one up and had a play with it. It’s way faster in the menu’s and the photo viewing, and I would even enjoy watching a video on it. Still, I noticed some performance problems when playing a song and scrolling through the Cover Flow at high speed. Somehow doing these things caused the music to “skip” repeatedly, but strangely we couldn’t repeat this skipping later on when we tried some other iPod Classics. Is this posibly a hardware defect or does it have something to do with the song I played?

In the end we really liked the iPod Nano as it is cheap, very portable (may I say it is a Shuffle competitor in size?) and the new Product Red color is very nice and funky. The ability to play video’s on it might seem trivial but it opens the world of Podcasts to those people who want to have something interesting to watch on the road. I am actually thinking of getting one myself, although I still love my Shuffle.

Monday, July 2nd, 2007

Review: Pownce Alpha

pownceSince Yesterday I have been able to have a quick review at Pownce (thank you Robert G.). Pownce literally has web2.0 written over it in all the bad ways: it has a weird name, it’s in Beta (or is it Alpha?), uses pastel colored themes, allows you to share stuff with your friends, is invite only, and is generally useless. Honestly, I love web2.0 technology but these guys are really pushing the hype.

As if things couldn’t get worse, they actually managed to ignore all the issues I discussed recently with Reinier: they are monetizing it even from this Alpha/Beta status, they offer something that (honestly) we don’t need, they are not really specific as you can share anything with anyone without really differentiating from let’s say an email, and it is clearly not viral. The last point might not be clear, but if you think about the fact that you almost never want to share random files with people then it makes sense. If you want to share specific things like photos or videos, you go to a site like Flickr or YouTube.

As Kevin Rose (guy behind Digg) is involved in this startup they are getting a lot of hype, but I think that’s sad as it takes focus away from the truly cool startups. In the end they did some stuff right though, as Pownce allows you to group friends and send files to individuals and groups. Additionally they launched a nice desktop application for Windows and Mac to share and get updates. Their tool uses Adobe AIR and has one problem though as SmudgyPixel noted yesterday:

All and all I think Pownce is a rubbish product in its current state, and I am already becoming pretty annoyed with all those “friends” of mine sending me “test” messages.

Tuesday, June 5th, 2007

The Next Web Summary

Silence before the stormThe Next Web is over and it is now time to have a good look at what happened. The conference was quite a lot of fun. For me it started at 7:30 AM when I arrived to help create the bloggers-booth where bloggers had a landlines internet connection. This booth was used by some grateful bloggers to do live write-ups of the speakers. I did all this hard work together with Sjors Timmer who had prepared most of the work. He wrote a very interesting wrietup of what The Next Web is:

“The next web is wireless (not mobile), The Next Web isn’t a web, The Next Web is about being connected, The Next Web is de-central, The Next Web is about love, The Next Web is a social prison, The Next Web will be transparent”

Startup LoungeOnce this task was done at 8:30 I decided to search for Jeroen and Reinier of TipIt.to because they were given a stand in the hall. All the startups with stands were pushed in a very narrow corner of the Tuschinski Theatre which was very regretful as it was dark, warm, and narrow. They could better have used the main entry where they put Adobe and Level3 (boring!).
(more…)

Wednesday, May 23rd, 2007

Wakoopa: Useless Tracker Tool?

At the beginning of this month we made an announcement of the release of Wakoopa - a tracker tool for applications.

Review of Wakoopa
Rated as 3/5 on May 23 2007 by Cristiano Betta

3/5

wakoopa logo

Much like Last.fm, Wakoopa has users install a tracker to monitor the behavior of the user. Where Last.fm focuses on music, Wakoopa tracks your use of applications. I have been using the tool for a while and I think that it might be one of the most useless trackers yet for a whole bunch of reasons.

1) Yes it is nice to see what others are using, but somehow there is a big difference between an application and a piece of music. Music involves passion, taste, and feeling while the most PC users use applications because they were either forced into that situation or because they have never looked beyond what was pre-installed on their PC. I have to admit that Wakoopa has the potential of solving that last issue.2) So maybe Wakoopa is nice for discovering new applications? I went to the Software page to see what others are using and what is recommended to me by Wakoopa. To summarize the statistics page the following can be concluded:

  • wakoopa softwareThe most common applications are browsers, in the following order: Firefox (?!?), Internet Explorer, Firefox (Again?!), Opera and Safari.
  • As a Mac user I am recommended the most common other Mac applications: iLife, iWork, etc. A bit too obvious I believe.
  • The second most interesting thing besides browsing is chatting using the MSN client.

3) So, I have some friends on Wakoopa with the same (forced) taste in applications, and I can see what other applications they use, and I might want to try these out. But will this make me happy? I don’t think there is any really interesting reason to go to the Wakoopa site and start trying out applications. Most of them will probably not be the most popular applications as I am already using these, which means that they are unlikely to really make me happy. Furthermore I believe that if an application can be really useful, I would probably feel sad for being so stupid before.

4) My final complaint is not that much a practical problem, but more a theoretical one: what is the Wakoopa business model? As there isn’t much reason to stay with Wakoopa, and as they don’t offer much extra (unlike Last.fm who offer a music station with your music) I am thinking how they get any income. Are they selling the information about the software I use? Is anyone ever going to sue them for their information as they keep record of all the illegal installations of Microsoft Office and other software? I think the privacy factor, though surely anticipated by the creators, is a bigger con than there are pros.

In short I think Wakoopa is fairly useless, and creates a bigger privacy issue than it offers new features. Maybe they are planning more but for now I am inclined to uninstall their tracker.

Review Tags: , ,
Rate this review at LouderVoice

Saturday, May 19th, 2007

LouderVoice: Reviewing the Review Tool

I recently posted a review about Webconverger, and to do this I used the LouderVoice technology. Today I do a review of this technology using their own system. LouderVoice really sounds like a good idea.

Review of LouderVoice
Rated as 4/5 on May 19 2007 by Cristiano Betta

4/5

LouderVoice is a simple tool, that uses a MicroFormat (hReview) to track reviews written by anyone around the world. The great thing of their system is that they let you post your reviews to your own blog/site/whatever instead of posting it to their site. In contrary to having a pool of reviews (much like Amazon’s reviews), the reviews posted with LouderVoice will be your property, located on your site, and easily searchable and discoverable by your readers. I like this decentralized system and therefore I gave it a try a few days ago with my review of WebConverger.

Now, posting this first review didn’t work that well. First of all I didn’t get that I had to actually subscribe LouderVoice to the FourStarters RSS feed, in contrary to having their service login to the Wordpress install (which is also an option). After I fixed this the review somehow still didn’t show up, which was (very professionally) solved within a day by Conor (founder) himself. Somehow they hadn’t thought of the fact that our RSS feed goes through FeedBurner and this broke their system. It all works fine now as you can see when you go to my review page.

LouderVoice is a technologically well implemented product, using the hReview MicroFormat and providing serveral ways to publish your reviews (bookmarklets, WordPress-plugins, on their site, etc). They only recently launched and I have been informed that they already had alot of feedback on how to improve the system. I, for example, think they should make it easier to add old reviews (like my N95 review, which isn’t present in our RSS feed anymore so won’t show up in their system). I think they will release all these small features that have been suggested in due time. I think that if more of us start using the tool and spamming them with ideas, the earlier they will add the features.

There isn’t that much content on LouderVoice yet, but it obviously takes time to build a good basis. I will start using their tool more often on FourStarters as we are used to doing reviews of website and applications. If you want, you can now go and rate the quality of this review here, or signup and start doing reviews on your own blog.

LouderVoice Review Tags:
Rate this review at LouderVoice

Sunday, May 13th, 2007

Review: Webconverger

One of the few “new technologies” I discovered during OpenCoffee but which I haven’t discussed yet is Webconverger by Kai Hendry. Kai managed to remind me of this at the last meeting so here is a review.

Review of WebConverger
Rated as 2/5 on May 13 2007 by Cristiano Betta

2/5

Introduction
Webconverger is a simple LiveCD that enables anyone to boot a pc and “run the web”. Basically it runs Debian with Firefox in kiosk mode, which enables you to browse and use web-apps around the world wherever you are. And all without exposing any personal details obviously. Webconverger (unfortunately) has some basic flaws which need to be solved before and can become even interesting as a solution.

Marketing

“Webconverger is an evolution of the hybrid client for deployments in places like offices or Internet cafes where only Web applications are used.” - this is the mindbogglingly difficult description on the website that wouldn’t stick with my mother. If I understand it right, then Webconverger is not aimed at tech-savvy geeks who own a laptop but at the average Joe who isn’t interested in tech. This makes this description so badly conceived that I think we have a clear case of unexperienced marketing. Webconverger really has to target these Joes to make them understand why this product is important to them! PresentationZen has a nice article about presentation and the big question that is left with Webconverger: “Why does this matter?”

Functionallity

booted-tabs.pngA major issue with tools like these is that they don’t matter to most people, and what makes them matter is good functionality. The persuasion that gets a person to use your tool instead of another tool is something that need a lot of time and intention, but it is always worth the trouble. Webconverger doesn’t add anything that will give the user the feeling of something of a “home on a CD”, and this is just what is needed to persuade an average Joe. For example, I can imagine that a normal person doesn’t use most of the web2.0 technologies to manage his online live, so some solution to quickly import bookmarks into his Firefox over the web would be a necessary functionality

Additionally I doubt that a user, in a place where he doesn’t want to or trusts to use the provided Operating System, is able to boot from this CD and connect to the internet. Configuring the internet access in a foreign place can be a hard thing to do that people just don’t want spent their time on. I think that techniques like U3 (although windows only) solve this problem perfectly as you keep using the OS but still carry around your own settings and applications on a USB drive.

CD’s are just too 1999!

Conclusion

Although it is a nice idea, and I really like Hendry’s enthusiasm, I think that Webconverger really needs a round of user-testing testing and and and extra development cycle to make it interesting to my mother. Sadly the current product is both too much of an hassle to the people who need it, and to little of a treat to the ones that need to be convinced.

Rate this review at LouderVoice

Saturday, May 12th, 2007

Preview: MyHippocampus.com

I came across MyHippocampus.com in a post on the Google Widget Toolkit newsgroups. This is not your ordinary webapp - so let’s have a closer look:

The basic idea of myhippocampus is mindmapping; a way to dump everything you’ve ever seen, read, learned or thought about into a website, so that you can search through it, visualize the evolution of your experiences, yadayada. When you see or read something new, you add the info to the site, and you’ll get back related thoughts and materials you’ve entered before, to give you some perspective.

That’s a tough pill to swallow though; “everything ever seen, read, learned or thought about” covers rather a lot of material, and it’s rather a lot of work to write it all down, so the ‘payoff’ - the ability to visualize it all, has to be large to even try. With this much info its also difficult to come up with useful visualizations. Still a closed beta, but fortunately there are screencasts to gawk at.

Remember the xkcd comic with the map of web communities? That same kind of interface is what MyHippocampus uses to map your life:

hippocampus1.png

Nifty, and on a technical note, impressively done without flash. You can zoom in and out as if it’s google maps; the more you zoom in, the more details appear. The basics of usability are there as well: simple full-text search at the bottom, and an index ‘glossary’ of sorts as well.

However, I wasn’t convinced this might just work until I saw the ways you can visualize your experiences. For example, I currently don’t track the books I’ve read nor the movies I’ve seen because writing it all down and coming up with interesting visualizations of the data is too much hassle. However, this timeline feature, which can handle as many ‘islands’ (like a tag, really) as you like, seems useful:

hippocampus2.png

The app also tracks where and when entries are made, comes with bookmarklets (think del.icio.us but with a world map visualization representing your tags and your bookmarks), and automatically links any content you focus on by giving you ‘neighbours’ in the dimension of time, location (in real life), location (on the map), and stuff you manually linked.

It’s certainly hip, but will it catch on? I don’t know yet. The biggest problem as I see it is difficulty in importing stuff you’ve already written down; some import wizards to grab your delicious bookmarks and e.g. amazon book lists would be a big help. There’s also no social aspect to speak of; it would be interesting to browse mindmaps of friends or people with similar tastes, for example.

You can see some screencasts here.

Thursday, May 3rd, 2007

Nokia N95 Review (Full)

I already did a small review of the new Nokia N95 last week, but today I will be going into some more detail about what makes the N95 “tick”. The first day I had my N95, I played around trying to get Jaiku working over GPRS, and then I installed Fring to be able to use Skype over the Wifi. Obviously all this tinkering quickly drained the battery so here is a more detailed overview of “what computers have become”.

Battery Life (+)

fring.jpgOne complaint of some reviewers is the battery life of the N95, but both I and another N95 owner noticed that this is probably only an issue in the first week because this is when you are playing around with all the functions. Once you start using the phone as a phone, and only occasionally use the display/video/GPS/wifi capabilities, the battery life is actually very acceptable. For me, even when using a lot of wifi, the battery life ranges from 1 to 1.5 days .

GPS (+/-)

GPS ToolThe built-in GPS receiver is what sets the N95 apart from the other Nokia N-series phones. Unfortunately the GPS receiver is of really bad quality, and the antenna is located in the keypad, so for reception you will have to slide open the screen. In the first days I couldn’t manage to get a fix, but I recently noticed that if you stand still under a blue sky, it is able to make a fix on your position within a minute or two. This isn’t quite quick enough to solve my GPS issue, but it is fun.

Amazingly though, once you do have a fix, it really manages to keep track of your position. Even in places (half inside a building for example) where you would not get an initial fix at all. I did notice some inaccuracy here and there but in the end it does it’s job. The software provided is pretty detailed and uses internet (wifi, GPRS, UMTS or other) to download your maps. I manually zoomed in to the London area once and that was enough to never again run out of cached maps. A nice addition is the built-in search engine for finding interesting places (hotels, restaurants, etc) in your current area.

(more…)